The Consumer Report.
Report No. 01 · November 2026Pre-salesSalesFinanceService

Where is the profit?

What moved dealership profit, and four moves that follow it.

In partnership withDealer General
Video 1:37 · 4 min read

Something moved in your store this year, and nobody sent a memo. This is where the profit went, what moved it, and four moves that follow it.

Chapter 01 · The profit point

Profit moved to the back of the store.

Take the second quarter of 2026 against a year earlier. Gross profit on each new vehicle fell 13.5 percent. Used fell 10 percent. In the same quarter, F&I income per vehicle reached $1,769, the highest in the benchmark's history, and service and parts gross grew 5.2 percent.

Figure 1 · Gross profit, change by departmentQ2 2026 against Q2 2025
Presidio-NCM dealership benchmark, second quarter 2026 against a year earlier, 4,000+ franchised stores. Published Aug. 4, 2026.

The front of the store got thinner. The back of the store is carrying it. Service and parts now bring in more than half of all gross profit.

Figure 2 · Share of gross profitService and parts
Up from 50.1% a year earlier. F&I income per vehicle, $1,769, is the highest in the benchmark's history. Presidio-NCM dealership benchmark, Q2 2026. Published Aug. 4, 2026.
Chapter 02 · What moved it

Won at the sale, then left to chance.

Three things pressed on the front. Customers are stretched: 54 percent of dealers say the economy is holding business back. Traffic is soft. And the advertised price now has to be the real price, so there is less to rebuild at the desk.

Meanwhile, people are keeping their cars longer, and every one of those years needs service. That is the back of the store's best customer. Here is where it leaks.

Figure 3 · The handoff after deliveryNew-vehicle buyers

Swipe to see the whole figure

80%of new-vehicle buyers say they will come back to you for service
1 in 4leave with a first service visit booked
$12,398of service spend lost with one customer who never comes back2.4 visits a year × 8.4 years × $615
Cox Automotive Fixed Operations and Ownership Study, Apr. 9, 2026. 2,502 consumers and 500 fixed-ops decision makers. One study.

That last number is one study's estimate, not a promise. But multiply it by last month's deliveries and the leak has a size.

Chapter 03 · Four lanes, four moves

Four lanes, four moves.

Each lane has one move the research points to. None of them is new, and every one of them is easy to skip on a busy day.

Lane 1Pre-sales
Your next used car is in your service drive.
Want a trade offer in the lane33%
Have ever been given one14%
Cox Automotive Fixed Ops and Ownership Study, 2026
Lane 2Sales
One price, shown early.
Dealers who call the process transparent68%
Buyers who agree21%
Capital One Car Buying Outlook, 2023
Lane 3Finance
Shorten the menu.
Dealer principals carrying eight or more products54%
Who name menu fatigue a top challenge23%
AutoPayPlus dealer principal survey, 2026. Vendor survey.
Lane 4Service
Book it. Show it.
+$230more per repair order when the recommendation comes with a photo or video, and 49% more likely to be approved
Cox Automotive Fixed Ops and Ownership Study, 2026
Figure 4 · One customer, four lanesDo all four and the lanes feed each other

Swipe to see the whole figure

Likely to buy their next vehicle from you
74%
Buyers who came back to you for service
44%
Buyers who did not
Cox Automotive 2026 Fixed Operations and Ownership Study and media deck. One study.

Buyers who come back for service are 30 points more likely to buy their next vehicle from you. The service lane is not where the sale ends. It is where the next one starts.

Chapter 04 · Who can help

One partner, every lane.

You don't have to build this alone, and there are good companies in every lane. Dealer General, the partner on this report, works across all four: vehicles ready and seen, ownership benefits that put your value in writing, protection your finance team can stand behind, and service-drive programs that bring the customer back. It has been at it since 1986.

Partner on this report · Since 1986
Lane 1Pre-sales
  • Reconditioning
  • Detail
  • Inventory photo
Lane 2Sales
  • C.L.U.B. Core
  • Ceramic coating
  • Window tint
Lane 3Finance
  • C.L.U.B. Complete
  • Warranty Platform
Lane 4Service
  • Drive Lane programs
  • Chemical program
  • Lifetime Parts

Ask your Dealer General representative for a review of your store, lane by lane.

Three questions to ask any partner, including this one
01Is the customer's value in writing?
02Which number does it move?
03Who trains my team?

How to read the numbers. Every figure in this report is published industry research, not a Dealer General result. Where only one study says it, the band below says so.

Sources and readings10 readings, each with its band

Usable: two independent sources that agree. Thin: one source, a vendor survey, or older data.

ReadingSourceBand
New gross per unit down 13.5%; used down 10.0%Presidio-NCM benchmark, via Digital Dealer, Aug. 4, 2026Usable
F&I income per retail unit $1,769, up 4.8%, highest in the seriesPresidio-NCM benchmark, Aug. 4, 2026Usable
Service and parts 52.8% of gross profit, from 50.1%; gross up 5.2%Presidio-NCM benchmark, Aug. 4, 2026Usable
54% of dealers name the economy as holding business backCox Automotive Dealer Sentiment Index, Sep. 8, 2026Usable
80% plan to return for service; about a quarter have a first visit bookedCox Automotive 2026 Fixed Operations and Ownership Study, Apr. 9, 2026Thin
$12,398 potential service spend; 74% against 44% likely to buy againCox Automotive ownership study page and media deck, 2026Thin
33% want a trade-in value during service; 14% have ever been offered oneCox Automotive 2026 Fixed Operations and Ownership StudyThin
68% of dealers call the process transparent; 21% of buyers agreeCapital One Car Buying Outlook 2023, via CBT NewsThin
54% carry eight or more F&I products; 23% name menu fatigue a top challengeAutoPayPlus survey, Aug. 4, 2026. Vendor survey.Thin
Photo or video: about $230 more per repair order; 49% more likely to approveCox Automotive 2026 Fixed Operations and Ownership StudyThin
Share this report LinkedIn Email
Next · Report No. 02

No. 02 is in production.

Share No. 01 with someone who runs a store, and check back here for the next lane.